Pizza restaurants

Mr. Pizza - Auburn

4.4 284 reviews 10:00 AM - 08:30 PM 69 Wall St, Auburn, NY 13021, United States

Discover this place

Mr. Pizza is a pizza restaurant located at 69 Wall St in Auburn, NY. It offers a classic American-style menu centered around a variety of pizzas. Signature options include multiple cheese blends and popular toppings such as pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and meatballs, with chicken available as an extra. Alongside pizzas, the menu features subs like the meatball sub and cheese steak mushrooms, as well as appetizers including Louisiana chicken wings, mozzarella sticks, and fried dough. Salads such as antipasto and grilled chicken provide lighter options. The atmosphere is casual and straightforward, focusing on delivering familiar, comforting flavors. Mr. Pizza serves as a local spot where residents can enjoy traditional pizza dishes complemented by a selection of sandwiches and sides, making it a well-rounded choice for a quick, informal meal in Auburn.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Mr. Pizza - Auburn before visiting.

Reviews for Mr. Pizza - Auburn

4.4

284 reviews

100%

25%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 284 reviews

Mr. Pizza in Auburn, NY, is consistently praised for its high-quality food and attentive service despite its small size. Customers frequently highlight the flavorful and well-prepared menu offerings, particularly the pizzas with their airy, crispy crusts and thoughtfully chosen toppings. The steak subs and wings also receive strong approval, noted for both taste and generous portioning. While some mention slightly higher prices, the overall consensus reflects satisfaction with the value provided. The restaurant maintains a welcoming and professional atmosphere, with staff recognized for their friendly and efficient approach even during busy periods. Regular patrons demonstrate strong loyalty, often traveling from neighboring areas to enjoy their favorite dishes, indicating a reliable and appealing dining experience at Mr. Pizza.

Chrissy

Jun 03, 2025

Yes, it's a very small pizza shop but the food is AMAZING. Service is ALWAYS pleasant and professional. Our go to is usually pizza or the grilled chicken salad. I've been trying to convince my fiance to try their steak subs as they are, hands down, the best I've ever had. He finally gave in and we had steak subs last night. He ordered a deluxe and I ordered the peppers and onions steak sub with extra peppers and onions. Both had mayo and mozzarella. He was amazed at how big, full and delicious it was. He said he's never getting another steak sub anywhere else BUT Mister Pizza. Couldn't recommend more!

Gaige Weese

May 29, 2025

Little pricey but no complaints...best sub I've ever had was from Mr Pizza

jamie Thomas

May 25, 2025

I come from Syracuse just for the half sheets of pizza. The crust is airy, crispy, fluffy, and a few small burnt parts add to the flavor that I crave. The cheese pizza is perfect but I like to add mushrooms and sausage. The sausage is small crumbly bits and not big fat chunks. I just can't say enough how much I love this pizza. My grown son also takes the ride from Syracuse when he wants to treat himself with a buffalo chicken pizza and grabs an extra pizza foe the family. There's a reason why Mr Pizza has been around so long

wing terrorist

May 22, 2025

My dad liked his cheesesteak but I wish he wouldve bought me cookies. Womp womp.

Benjamin Kaiser

May 09, 2025

Tonight I ordered a Philly steak and cheese no veggies and the Louisiana wings. I am new to the area and didn't know what to expect. When I entered Mr pizza it was obvious they where busy kicking out food. One of the guys working helped me right away. He was really nice. I got my food, headed to my hotel and I have to say, it's really good. I would recommend this to anyone. I have not tried the pizza but I will when I get a chance.

Jeff Bryant

Apr 30, 2025

This is the best Sicilian style pizza I've ever had.

Rocko Dorsey

Mar 26, 2025

The pizza is delicious and the subs on their homemade rolls is by far the greatest I have ever had anywhere. If that isn't enough to gain them a 5 star review, try their cookies!

Steve Schmid

Mar 19, 2025

Ordered here a bunch this past year and it's always been great, prices are very reasonable including delivery. One of the very few places I get delivery since it's not door dash or similar. Came back to Auburn after 15 years away and was shocked at how much some of the other pizza places have fallen off so it's been Mr Pizza 100% of the time lately.